Total Pageviews

Dick Costolo, Master of Improv, Writing Twitter\'s Script

Peter DaSilva for The New York Times

Dick Costolo was a stand-up comedian years before becoming the chief at Twitter. He has been unafraid to buck convention as he guides the company toward a possible I.P.O.

WELCOME to the Dick Costolo Show.

The audience, le beau monde of cinema, has gathered at the Debussy Theater on this unseasonably cool May morning on the French Riviera. The event, officially the opening of the 2012 Cannes Film Festival, will be remembered for freakish storms that left stars shivering on the soaked red carpet.

But before the Palme d'Or, a little stand-up comedy from Mr. Costolo, the chief executive of . He has prepared some sober remarks for the occasion - a paean to the mighty tweet, an explication of how new tools of social media are reinventing business, social activism and everything in between.

Nah. Out goes the script.

“Since I've got 45 minutes, if we can just start with some quick introductions,” he says, gesturing to the front row. “Start over here. Stand up, say what company you're from and what animal you could be if you could be any animal.”

So goes his keynote speech at Cannes.

It's not quite as strange as it sounds. Long before the Twitter revolution and his ascent to the heights of social media, Mr. Costolo was a professional comedian. And you know what? He's still doing improv - only it's the business kind. He'll wax on about growth and revenue like the next C.E.O. But then he'll dig out a joke and do something that might hurt his business - and miff his investors - because, well, he thinks that something is the right thing to do.

He has broken with the pack on the issue of patent infringement, an issue that drives the tech world crazy, and, in stark contrast to Facebook, has let newcomers to the site opt out of being tracked through the service - a daring move, given that Twitter makes money from advertising.

Even in Silicon Valley, that Neverland of Mark Zuckerberg and hoodied Lost Boy executives, Mr. Costolo can seem an un-C.E.O. To which he says, essentially, whatever.

“People have Plato's form in their mind of what a leader is, or what a C.E.O. is, and it is a bunch of elements that I really don't conform to at all,” Mr. Costolo says. “I've given this a lot of thought, and I came to the conclusion that I don't care.”

That kind of attitude could take Twitter to heretofore unimaginable success. Or it could turn it into a B-school case study of a start-up company gone wrong. The choice, for the moment, is Mr. Costolo's. Today, Twitter seems ubiquitous. But this company didn't even exist seven years ago. Bankrolled by venture capitalists, it has grown into a multibillion-dollar enterprise with 140 million users worldwide. Although the company doesn't share its financials, it is estimated that it will have $350 million in revenue this year. “We're an entire quarter ahead of our projected goals,” one executive says.

Its next big step is to go public on the stock market, and insiders say the current goal is to have an initial public offering in 2014. Twitter's social media twin, Facebook, has already gone public, of course - and, so far, Facebook stockholders have lost billions, at least on paper. Facebook's troubled I.P.O. hangs over the technology industry as a cautionary tale of how investors can become star-struck.

Mr. Costolo didn't found Twitter. Jack Dorsey, Christopher Stone and Evan Williams did. But today Mr. Costolo is essentially running the business alone, and friends and colleagues say he is eager to build the company. And he has succeeded before. During the early 1990s, he worked at Andersen Consulting to subsidize his comedy career. He tried to explain this thing called the World Wide Web to his bosses, but, he says, they didn't listen. So he and several co-workers started their own consulting firm, Burning Door Networked Media, specializing in Web projects.

Mr. Costolo went on to help found and sell three companies. One of them, Spyonit, notified people when a Web site changed. (This was a decade before anyone had heard the term “real time.”) People used Spyonit to monitor auctions on eBay and to see when comment threads were updated on Web forums. Another of his companies, FeedBurner, helped bloggers syndicate content. FeedBurner was sold to Google in 2007 for more than $100 million.

But starting a small company and then selling it to a big one, difficult as it can be, seems easy next to taking Twitter to the next level. On paper, Twitter is valued at close to $10 billion. That means the most likely exit strategy for its initial backers - notably Charles River Ventures, Benchmark Capital, Union Square Ventures and Mr. Costolo himself - would be to take the company public. But after the Facebook fiasco, Mr. Costolo will have to persuade Wall Street that Twitter, and its share price, could keep rising.

His audience - Wall Street, Silicon Valley and the wider world - is waiting for his next act.



The Shadow of Steve Jobs in Apple\'s Maps Problem

The company's bundling of its mapping technology with the iPhone 5 brings to mind the Microsoft-Netscape antitrust battles of the 1990s.

Who Invented The Escape Key?

Jens Mortensen for The New York Times

“It's the ‘Hey, you! Listen to me' key,” says Jack Dennerlein of the Harvard School of Public Health. According to Dennerlein, an expert on how humans interact with computers, the escape key helped drive the computer revolution of the 1970s and '80s. “It says to the computer: ‘Stop what you're doing. I need to take control.' ” In other words, it reminds the machine that it has a human master. If the astronauts in “2001: A Space Odyssey” had an ESC key, Dennerlein points out, they could have stopped the rogue computer Hal in an instant.

The key was born in 1960, when an I.B.M. programmer named Bob Bemer was trying to solve a Tower of Babel problem: computers from different manufacturers communicated in a variety of codes. Bemer invented the ESC key as way for programmers to switch from one kind of code to another. Later on, when computer codes were standardized (an effort in which Bemer played a leading role), ESC became a kind of “interrupt” button on the PC - a way to poke the computer and say, “Cut it out.”

Why “escape”? Bemer could have used another word - say, “interrupt” - but he opted for “ESC,” a tiny monument to his own angst. Bemer was a worrier. In the 1970s, he began warning about the Y2K bug, explaining to Richard Nixon's advisers the computer disaster that could occur in the year 2000. Today, with our relatively stable computers, few of us need the panic button. But Bob Frankston, a pioneering programmer, says he still uses the ESC key. “There's something nice about having a get-me-the-hell-out-of-here key.”

I, KEYBOARD

Joseph Kay is a senior scientist at Nokia Research Center.

Why do outmoded keys, like ESC, persist? Our devices have legacies built into them. For more than a hundred years, when you wanted to write something, you sat down in front of a typewriter. But computers look different now - they're like smartphones. It will be interesting to see whether in 10 or 15 years the whole idea of a keyboard will seem strange. We might be saying, “Remember when we used to type things?”

How would we control computers in this future-without-typing? Think of the Wii and Kinect, or even specialized input devices for games like Guitar Hero or Dance Dance Revolution. All might be bellwethers for the rest of computing. We might see a rise in all sorts of input, like voice recognition and audio control - think about Siri.



Photographs of the First Snow of the Season on Twitter

By JENNIFER PRESTON

An early-season snowstorm blanketed northwestern Minnesota and parts of North Dakota on Thursday, shutting schools, pulling down power lines and making trouble for farmers already struggling to salvage crops from the worst drought in 50 years.

As my colleague Timothy Williams reports, the heaviest snow fell on the small town of Roseau, Minn., 10 miles from the Canadian border. It got 14 inches.

Daryl Ritchison, a meteorologist for television and radio stations in Fargo, N.D., said that snow this time of year was unusual, even for North Dakota.

On his Twitter feed, Mr. Ritchison shared photos from viewers showing the effects of the storm, including two submitted by Douglas Langer from Thief River Falls, Minn.

In northwestern Minnesota, snow continued falling Friday morning. The official Twitter account for Sgt. Jesse Grabow, the Northwestern Minnesota State Patrol public information officer, reported at least one fatality related to the storm.

The wintry weather meant classes were canceled or delayed for many students.

For some farmers, including those in the fertile Red River Valley, the snow and sudden drop in temperature made a difficult harvest even more challenging as it raised concern about soybeans and late-maturing corn.

In Denver, people woke up on Friday to find the first snow of the season, inspiri ng some to snap photos of the layer covering their windshields, patios and backyards - or an image of a snow-covered football field, which is what Brock Osweiler, the backup quarterback for the Denver Broncos, shared on Twitter.

In Colorado, ski resorts quickly got out the message that they had snow, sending photos of ski runs and a hashtag, #WinterIsBack

As the snow and strong cold front continued to move east, promising below-normal temperatures for the East Coast this weekend, the updates on Twitter continued, including posts expressing dismay that yes, #WinterIsHere.