Total Pageviews

Images of Emancipation

#flashHeader{visibility:visible !important;}

The portrait for the carte-de-visite of Sojourner Truth, the African-American abolitionist and women's rights advocate, was taken in Battle Creek, Mich., in the 1860s (Slide 5). She wears an elegant silk dress and shawl. With one hand resting on her hip, the other on the arm of the chair, her pose is majestic and determined. She stares resolutely into the camera.

But it is the object in her lap that remains one of the image's most revelatory details: an open daguerreotype of her grandson James Caldwell, a soldier during the Civil War.

The daguerreotype's pride of place speaks not only to Truth's love for her grandchild but also to her passionate engagement with photography. As Deborah Willis and Barbara Krauthamer write in their groundbreaking new book, “Envisioning Emancipation: Black Americans and the End of Slavery” (Temple University Press), Truth was probably the first black woman to actively distribute photographs of herself.

Those pictures were meant to affirm her status as a sophisticated and respectable “free woman and as a woman in control o f her image.” The public's fascination with carte-de-visites, small and collectible card-mounted photographs, allowed her to advance her abolitionist cause to a huge audience and earn a living through their sale. “I Sell the Shadow to Support the Substance,” proclaimed the famous slogan for these pictures.

DESCRIPTIONCourtesy of the Library of Congress Susie King Taylor, 1902.

Truth was not alone in her understanding of the power of photography. A host of other African-Americans, both eminent and ordinary, employed the medium as an instrument of political engagement and inspiration. “Envisioning Emancipation” argues that photography was not incidental but central to the war against slavery, racism and segregation in the antebellum period of the 1850s through the New Deal era of the 1930s.

The book explores how blacks “positioned themselves and were posed by others” in order to advance, question or alter prevailing ideas about race. It examines the ways the national debate about slavery was played out in photographs, for example, from the standpoint of abolitionists, who published them as proof of the brutality and immorality of slavery, and its supporters, who engaged photographs as visual evidence of its “natural order and orderliness.”

Pseudoscientists, like Louis Agassiz, the Swiss-born and Harvard-trained zoologist, adapted the medium to further notions of black aberrance and inferiority. Agassiz employed invasive daguerreotypes of naked slaves - the “pornography of forced labor,” as they have been aptly described - to verify his theory of polygenesis, the separate human origins of Africans and Europeans, and emphasize the relative lowliness of the former.

Abolitionists used photographs to convince Northern whites - for whom the prospect of emancipation elicited responses ranging from skepticism to violence - of the unjustness of slavery. They stirred public sentiment by offering visual evidence of slavery's abuses as well as of the wholesomeness of an emerging class of freed blacks. Juxtaposing pictures of hapless children, posed barefoot and dressed in ragged clothes, with images of the same children wearing neatly pressed and undamaged garments, for example, abolitionists were able to convey the idea that a formerly enslaved people, now rendered as attractive and healthy, were worthy of liberation.

DESCRIPTIONAugustus Washington, Courtesy of the Library of Congress Urias Africanus McGill, a Baltimore-born merchant, in Liberia. 1854.

As Ms. Willis and Ms. Krauthamer note, freedom for African-Americans was not instantly achieved with the implementation of the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863; it evolved fitfully, over many decades. During that time, it was photographs created largely by and for African-Americans that helped an oppressed people to imagine their own freedom. Prominent black leaders, including Frederick Douglass and Harriet Tubman, routinely turned to the medium, much as Sojourner Truth did, to further their abolitionist campaigns.

Soon, increasingly inexpensive imaging technology, coupled with a growing national network of black-owned photo studios, permitted African-Americans of all economic classes, even “the servant girl,” as Douglass observed, to construct their own versions of themselves. This affirmative imagery served to countermand destructive and pervasive stereotypes, steeling African-Americans against the ruthless forces of intolerance while simultaneously convincing white people of their shared humanity.

In the end, “Envisioning Emancipation” recounts a dynamic history of black self-possession and self-determination, one that challenges the abiding myth of the crusade against slavery and segregation: that of passive black victims who obtained freedom mostly through the benevolence and generosity of their white saviors.

DESCRIPTIONHenry P. Moore, Courtesy of the Library of Congress Sweet potato planting, James Hopkinson's plantation, 1862.

That myth does not die easily. It haunts popular culture, no more so than in Steven Spielberg's just-released film about the 16th president's epic battle against slavery, “Lincoln.” Despite the nuanced portrayal of its protagonist, “Lincoln” is almost devoid of images of active black resistance and protest, ignoring a wealth of research “demonstrating that slaves were crucial agents in their emancipation,” as the historian Kate Masur wrote last month in this newspaper.

“For my community, the message has been clear,” the writer Ta-Nehisi Coates recently observed, “the Civil War is a story for white people - acted out by white people, and on white people's terms - in which blacks feature strictly as stock characters and props.” “Envisioning Emancipation” brilliantly rewrites this story, insisting that we acknowledge the names and faces of people who have been invisible for too long.

DESCRIPTIONCourtesy of the Library of Congress Two brothers in arms, 1860s.

Maurice Berger is a research professor and the chief curator at the Center for Art, Design and Visual Culture at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, and a consulting curator at the Jewish Museum in New York. He is the author of 11 books, including a memoir, “White Lies: Race and the Myths of Whiteness.” Mr. Berger has worked with Ms. Willis on exhibitions and publications.

Follow @MauriceBerger and @nytimesphoto on Twitter.



Finding a Long Shot in Mexico

#flashHeader{visibility:visible !important;}

Arriving on assignment in San Juan Teotihuacan, Mexico, I expected to see the ancient Pyramid of the Sun - the largest structure in the area - dominating every vista.

Yet when I set foot in the parking lot of the sprawling Bodega Aurrera supermarket owned by Wal-Mart, the subject of my story, the pyramid was no where to be seen.

I was puzzled because I had seen a photograph taken in 2004 by a Reuters photographer showing the supermarket's construction. In the picture (Slide 1), the Pyramid of the Sun appears to loom just behind the store, but in reality, it is nearly a mile away.

That widely seen image captured the hot-button debates surrounding the store's arrival, which pitted its corporate owners, Wal-Mart, against local residents who wanted to protect the area's vibrant public markets, rich cultural history and significant archaeological sites. There were protests, hunger strikes and allegations of corruption.

Back then, a poet named Homero Aridjis said building the store in Teotihuacan was like “driving the stake of globalization into the heart of Mexican antiquity.”

In April, Mr. Barstow revealed how Wal-Mart's leaders shut down an internal investigation that had found strong evidence the company accelerated its rapid expansion in Mexico with millions of dollars in bribes. Now - in a story just published - he traced the history of the Teotihuacan case.

As a photographer, this is one of the hardest assignments to take on - an investigation into events that happened eight years ago. Since then, tensions have calmed, the store has already been built and previous governmental investigations in Mexico have cleared politicians of wrongdoing.

Knowing we would need archival photos, the photo editor Nancy Weinstock and I began looking for pictures taken in 2004, during the height of this conflict. That's when we found the Reuters photographer Henry Romero's widely seen photo of the pyramid and construction workers on the store's roof perfectly illustrated the cultural clash at the heart of the protests. If fact, the image spurred others to speak out in defiance.

As I prepared to go to Mexico again, I was excited that I'd be able to make a contemporary photo to compare with his and show the fully constructed store in the shadow of the pyramid. So, on my first trip to Mexico, we went to Teotihuacan and searched for his angle. When I looked at his photo I thought the store was right next to the pyramid.

But when I arrived at the Bodega Aurrera and walked around the parking lot, the pyramids were nowhere to be seen.

Looking at a map, we saw that the Pyramid of the Sun was far to the northeast of the store, so we walked, trying to find an angle that showed both. There is a river bed alongside the store, so we walked about a half mile looking for the location Mr. Romero had used years before. When we finally walked far enough to see the pyramid in the background, it was a tiny speck on the horizon.

I realized that to show the two the way Mr. Romero had, I would need a very long telephoto lens to compress the space. I tried a 400mm, but couldn't make a photo showing the store and the pyramid. With no workers on the roof for context, the image fell flat. Besides, I felt guilty taking the photo, because the store is not actually situated at the foot of the pyramid the way the 2004 image makes it appear. The Pyramid of the Sun is almost a mile away from the store, but the telephoto lens used in 2004 compressed the space to make them look closer than they actually are.

So, do we run the photo? After all, the paper used it in 2004 for an article about the conflict. There were spirited discussions about the ethics of running it, and I drew maps of the area for my editors.

To be clear, using a telephoto lens is accepted practice among photojournalists and there is nothing inherently unethical about using it to compress space. In this case, we believed, the use of a longer lens distorted distance, and therefore reality.

Ultimately, we decided not to publish Mr. Romero's photo this time. On first glance, it seemed to be the perfect visual précis for the story. But having been there - even going aloft in a hot-air balloon to scout out the distance - we felt some might fault the paper for visual manipulation. Explaining the optics and compression that produced the 2004 image would only distract from the story's meticulously reported details.

“It looks intriguing until you research it and you can see it's really not piled right on top, but there's actually quite a distance,” said Ms. Weinstock, who is a picture editor for numerous investigative stories. “Clearly, it had to be an enormously long lens. That in itself is distorting and isn't real. It's not showing the re ality of the thing. Since we're trying to tease out the reality of how this store got to be built, to run something inaccurate and visually distorting, I don't think we should run such a thing.”

In a statement, Heather Carpenter, a Reuters spokeswoman, said: “The use of long lenses is standard photo journalism practice and many news organizations, including Reuters and The New York Times, use them as a matter of routine. We were given limited time to look into the questions raised by The New York Times and are reviewing the matter.”

Mr. Aridjis, the same poet quoted in The New York Times in 2004, wrote an Op-Ed in April reflecting on Mr. Barstow's first investigative article, which investigated allegations that Wal-Mart de Mexico may have paid $24 million in bribes to open stores throughout the early 2000s. This time, the image illustrating the piece was of a Wal-Mart atop the Pyramid of the Sun.

It was powerful. It was a cartoon.

Scott Menchin


Pictures of the Day: Pakistan and Elsewhere

#flashHeader{visibility:visible !important;}

Photos from Pakistan, Connecticut, South Korea and Greece.

Follow Lens on Facebook and Twitter.